Zane says " I think Piper is scared. Look, you guys have Rivervale, it's there. If Goldfinch alters or changes and you don't like it, you can wave it bye bye and go back to the Lodge. Maybe I'm reading cuz wrong but she's.. she likees Rivervale, but I think for her it's like visiting a museum. You can admire, you can take a seat ... but it's not something she feels a part of so much as a guest. It's important because Siv considers it a home. Suddenly ther'es Goldfinch, and the magic is about tolerence, acceptence, no judgement... and Piper really really needs a place she feels accepted and her past isn't hanging around her neck. Not saying Rivervale does that, but Goldfinch is more satyr like? Piper can relax here. She can chip in in a burst and help scared kids one minute, then go into her studio with Linwood for hours and do nothing but jam sesson and either is okay. Low expectations, low pressures, but a lot of love for it. I"m not saying she's afraid of responsilbity, but something as blatant as hold ruling is.. how do you 'pretend' thats not super serious and binding? You can't. And I don't know if she has doubts with self worth or she just wants to be able to walk free and clear to other venues or a mix but she LOVES this hold and telling her it might become something she doesn't love? It would be like ... telling her that Jonas has decided to become a boast filled warrior interested only in battle, or Siv will go super demure and timid"